Blog Layout

Case Study: Replacing V-Packings with Nested Spring Energized Seals

Doug Montgomery • August 13, 2024

V-Packings, also called V-Stacks or chevron packings, have been around for decades and represent one of the earliest advanced sealing designs. While existing long before PTFE spring energized came into being, they are still used in a variety of industries today. Eclipse designs and manufactures its fair share of custom V-packings out of various materials every year. 


V-Packings offer a simple yet effective design principle. A series of nested “Vees” are arranged in a gland where the points of the Vees serve as the sealing contact points in the hardware. They are designed in such a way that if the stack is compressed axially, the Vee behind will expand the radial cross-sectional width of the Vee in front of it. This will provide the needed energy to force the contacting sealing points into the hardware surfaces.

Compression force is usually provided by a packing nut in the hardware. The more the stack is compressed, the tighter the sealing potential. This offers big advantage over other simple seal designs such as rope packings because the seal can be energized in focused locations. If leakage is occurring, tightening the packing nut if often all that’s needed.


V-Packings are often used in heavy industrial applications where a robust and substantial seal is needed. The numbers of Vees in the stack represent the number of effective sealing points. Eclipse has designed manufactured packings with up to ten Vees, but the only real limit is axial gland space in the system. In these heavy industrial applications, the ability to affect sealing performance by turning a wrench is well utilized where system maintenance is regularly performed and monitored.


While V-packings can work well in the right application, there are drawbacks to the design. A spring energized seal offers numerous advantages over V-packings and in many cases can outperform them in all major sealing aspects.


The Client’s Issue


Eclipse was approached by a customer looking for improved efficiency and longer seal wear life in their Natural Gas compressor. The compressor piston rod seal was currently using a Virgin PTFE V-Packing, and while it was working sufficiently, the customer was looking for improved compressor performance. All system aspects were under review for enhancement, including the seals.


Operating Conditions:


  • Reciprocating Rod Seal
  • Compressor Type: Single Acting, Crosshead Piston
  • 1.125” Rod Diameter
  • Stroke Length: 4”
  • Piston Speed: 850 FPM
  • Media: Natural Gas
  • Operating Pressure: 5,000 PSI


The Eclipse Solution


Eclipse knew that replacing the current V-Packing with a spring energized seal could potentially provide the customer with all the improvements they were looking for. While V-Packings certainly serve their purpose, they have a few limitations and drawbacks a spring energized seal does not.


The only energy applied in a V-Packing is from the initial compression in the hardware. In the case of PTFE, where it’s material properties essentially provide zero internal energy or elasticity, the initial compression energy will eventually diminish as the material relaxes and becomes worn.


Thus, a V-Packing will need maintenance over its lifespan. If leakage starts occurring, tightening the packing nut, or compression device will be necessary. But this also leads to a major disadvantage of a V-Packing with the imprecise way of loading the seal. A stack needlessly compressed too tight will experience accelerated wear and introduce excessive friction on the shaft.


A spring energized seal solves this problem. Its internal springs are a known and calculated value, providing the optimum sealing load at all times. This loading can be tailored to the application whether heavy scraping is needed or extreme low friction. 

Unlike a V-Packing, the spring will properly load the seal over its entire wear life. Therefore, essentially maintenance free operation is possible along with much more consistent loading and friction. The seal is no longer dependent on an operator to adjust as needed.


Many customers like the fact that a V-Packing has multiple sealing points for redundancy. In a retro-fit situation, as in this case, the customer wanted to retain this aspect of the seal. Eclipse replicated this feature by using nested cantilever V-Springs within the seal jacket. The external seal lips were machined with point contact locations the correspond to each spring. Thus, multiple energized contact points were maintained.


Whereas a V-Packing uses separate rings to achieve these redundant sealing points, the spring energized seal accomplishes this in a single, self-contained seal. It is no longer necessary to assemble the separate rings during installation, reducing part count and eliminating the potential for assembly error.


Eclipse chose its ET014: Polyamide filled PTFE for the seal jacket material. While Eclipse can custom machine a V-Stack set out of any of its filled PTFE options, most V-Stacks are usually just Virgin PTFE by default. This leaves a huge potential for wear life improvement by switching to a filled PTFE material. Eclipse used ET014 because the customers shaft hardness was below what was recommended for aggressive fillers. ET014 would provide a significant improvement in wear life while not damaging or deteriorating the hardware.


How It Performed



Eclipse’s spring energized seal met all the customer’s objectives in improving the efficiency and maintenance intervals of their compressor. The spring energized seal provided lower and much more consistent friction therefore improving the overall running efficiency of the whole mechanical compressing system.


The seal also no longer requires regular attending to perform optimally. This combined with the longer wearing ET014 seal material extended rebuild intervals greatly, thus saving the customer both time and money. The reduced part count and ease of seal installation were an added bonus to the project.


Contact Eclipse today if you think you can benefit by replacing a V-Packing with a custom spring energized seal >

By Doug Montgomery November 25, 2024
Eclipse has engineered sealing solutions for applications all over the planet and in a plethora of environments. From the bottom of the ocean to orbiting the earth, Eclipse is challenged by the unique conditions in each application. Whether it be extreme temperature and pressure or severely caustic or abrasive media, Eclipse has a solution for most every sealing problem. One distinct environment presents a particularly challenging set of circumstances for seal design – high radiation. Eclipse’s primary seal material choice for many applications is PTFE and PTFE blends. With all the wonderful attributes PTFE possesses as a seal material, radiation resistance is not one. In high radiation environments PTFE’s properties can degrade to essentially rule it out as a suitable material. The options for effective sealing materials that are also radiation resistant becomes very limited. The seal designer is therefore confronted with creating a seal that is expected to perform in every way a typical PTFE seal operates, out of materials that are not as favorable to sealing. This is where Eclipse’s engineering experience and expertise in seal design come to the forefront. The Client's Issue Eclipse was approached by a customer that was looking for a seal solution for a sensor used in a nuclear application. It would be operating in an environment with both high temperature and high Gamma radiation. Operating Conditions:
 Reciprocating Rod Seal
 Rod Diameter: Ø1.000
 Stroke: 1.5”
Cycle Rate: 2-4 cycles per minute
 Media: Air, Salt Water Mist
 Pressure: 100 PSI
 Temperature: 70° to 450°F
 Gamma Radiation Exposure: 10^6 rads
By Doug Montgomery November 14, 2024
Technological advancements in the area of robotics have led to more and more life-like creations existing only in works of science fiction a few decades ago. Development in autonomous logic processing and sensing allows bipedal robots to walk over uneven ground, up and down stairs, open doors and carry loads. Fast response to dynamic and unpredictable real-world environments is critical for the future use of robots in true-life service and practical employment in the years to come. While software and sensor development remain the primary focus of most research, the physical mechanics of next-gen robotics are also continually progressing. Physical components and control systems such as hydraulic pumps and cylinders, servo motors, and structural members are under pressure to continually be lighter, stronger, more efficient and less expensive. Increased demands on the physical components facilitate the need for innovative solutions in design and material usage. Advancements in construction and technology have spilled into all areas of robotic mechanisms and the many seals located throughout the system need to meet the challenges of tomorrow. Eclipse has been at the forefront of this research and has developed innovative solutions pushing the boundaries of conventional sealing devices. MicroLip™ by Eclipse is a prime example of most demanding applications forging new technologies in the sealing world. The Client's Issue Eclipse was approached by a leading robotics company looking for a sealing solution operating under a challenging set of conditions. While many components of tomorrow’s robotics are now controlled and actuated by servo/stepper motors and various electronic devices, the heaviest and most powerful movements are still driven by traditional hydraulics. The constant demand for more powerful hydraulic actuation in ever deceasing size and weight requirements has put tremendous strain on component design. But if robots are to progress to the point where they are usefully employed in the world, high power in a compact design is necessary. A robot, for example, used to survey and assist in a disaster zone too unstable for normal rescuers, must fit through doorways and over obstacles yet still be physically strong enough to render assistance. Large hydraulic systems are capable of moving extremely heavy loads but size and weight constraints of a humanoid size robot limit potential. The robot’s internal power supply to drive all components is also a limiting factor. Our client was developing a new hydraulic pump to drive all major motion aspects of their robotic systems. Their main objective was to minimize the pump’s physical size as much as possible while increasing output and improving power consumption efficiency. This means higher pressures and speeds on increasingly smaller and lighter components. Application Parameters: Shaft Diameter: Ø9.5mm Seal Housing Envelope: 5mm radial cross-section by 6mm axial width Rotational Speed: 3,500 RPM nominally; 6,000 RPM max Operating Pressure: 125 PSI min, 225 PSI nominal, 350 PSI max Surface Finish: 0.04µm Media: Hydraulic Oil While the above combination of pressure and speed might present difficulties for any conventional seal alone, the client’s extremely small physical envelope to house the seal further complicated the matter. If that wasn’t enough, the application presented the additional sealing challenge of up to 0.003” [0.08mm] of shaft runout. As part of the downsizing of all components in the pump, shaft support bearings were minimized leading to the possibility of runout. The wobbling effect of the shaft creates problems as the sealing lip has follow a moving, uneven mating surface, therefore potential leak-paths are created. Wear life can also be compromised due to higher concentrations of uneven loads. The combination of high pressure, high speed, high runout and minimal gland size present a worst-case scenario for a typical seal. Unsurprisingly, the client faced leakage of hydraulic fluid after only short periods of service with any conventional seal they had tested. Eclipse knew the had the perfect solution for this application. One developed to handle such extreme rotary sealing conditions: MicroLip™.
By Doug Montgomery October 14, 2024
How Eclipse reverse-engineered custom PTFE gaskets to restore a brewery’s historic equipment, ensuring leak-free connections and consistent, quality beer production.
By Doug Montgomery September 10, 2024
Custom piston seal rings by Eclipse enhance compressor performance, offering dry-run capability and extended wear life without hardware modifications.
Share by: